Tue 3 Feb 2009
Untrained Melody
Posted by anaglyph under Geek, Idiots, In The News, Laughs, Music
[16] Comments
A little while back I wrote about a project that Microsoft had in development called ‘MySong’. As you will recall, MySong was a software gew-gaw that analysed a singing human voice and then, supposedly, arranged a musical accompaniment for it. A YouTube video that was included with the breathless press release for MySong featured a tuneless singer showing us how MySong could manufacture a suitably tuneless musical arrangement for her atonal warbling. You will also remember not being surprised that I was fairly scathing of MySong and its potential.
Well, Mr Gates didn’t listen to me (he never does) and has ploughed ahead to commercially release the software under the name of SongSmith.™ Here’s a little ad about how SongSmith™ will Change Your Life!™
Now, get up off the floor and calm down. Because Reverend Anaglyph is going to astound you by declaring that SongSmith™ is a work of genius. I had mistakenly jumped to the conclusion that the aim of SongSmith™ was to try and make average normal Mary or Joe sound like a pop star, but I was wrong! It can now be revealed that Microsoft is much cleverer than I had ever imagined and that the real purpose of SongSmith™ is to show the average normal Mary or Joe that pop stars can’t really sing either! The only thing between the offerings of professional cash-earning musicians and the bathroom yodelling of the non-talented proletariat is the musical arrangement of their songs!
Not following me? Here, take a look at this and all will become clear – this is The Police, performing Roxanne, as Songsmith™ reveals Sting’s true talent!
I know exactly what you’re thinking – how did this man ever go on to release a string of solo CDs, make millions of dollars and land a part in Dune?!
You may want to go on and do some further investigation on your ownsome – YouTubers have been busy concocting all manner of new arrangements of your favourite artists. Discover that Marvin Gaye was a toneless moaner; marvel at how Radiohead ever made it to Number One with this abominable whining; wonder how Oasis ever got Wonderwall played on the radio with this irritating caterwauling! (Oh, very well, I guess it does make Van Halen slightly more entertaining… actually, a LOT more entertaining…)
Apple raised the barrier with iPhoto, iMovie and Garage Band to show normal, average people that they, too, could produce professional quality creative works with just some nicely produced software enablers. Microsoft once more has galloped to the fore to trump them, by demonstrating that in reality no-one has any true skill at all, and in fact the world is full of talentless schmucks.
I guess it helps make them feel better.
___________________________________________________________________________
UPDATE: Sadly, the Sting video embedded above has been removed. But this moving version of Motorhead’s ‘Ace of Spades’ might serve to illustrate my point.
I think my favorite thing about the whole ad is that the man and his daughter create their whole song on an Apple MacBook Pro. Why not just arrange something in GarageBand?
I think I got new favorite Youtube Videos!
I was waiting for Malach to explain it to me as usual, but that post is useless.
Atlas: Yes, the irony is not lost on me. Of course, to get something happening in Garage Band, you do need a modicum of talent, which is plainly lacking in the people in the ad.
Microsoft has begun this whole thing with a premise that is deeply flawed: that everyone should have the opportunity to make music, no matter how desperately lacking in any musical aptitude they are. Wrong, wrong, wrong! Just as not everyone is suited to be a front row forward or a ballet dancer or a portrait painter, some people will NEVER be musicians. Software, no matter how good, will not be a sufficient substitute for capability, whatever your level of enthusiasm.
This is in direct contrast to what Apple has done with Garage Band. Garage Band is an enabling tool – it gives people a simple window into the way music (well, pop music anyway) is actually made, rather than attempting to do the thinking for them.
Malach: I think SongSmith is made for someone exactly like you – no talent except for a penchant for annoying people.
Pil: Malach probably thinks it’s a fabulous idea.
I haven’t picked myself up off the floor yet
More bad music, just what I need.
The King
Nurse Myra: It’s like watching a car accident isn’t it. Grimly fascinating, and you can’t turn away no matter how horrible it gets.
King Willy: Not even your magic touch could save a SongSmith ditty. Now prepare yourself for all those Christians with their Songs of Praise albums…
This was featured on The Colbert Report this week.
You had me at glow-in-the-dark towels.
Courtesy of Count Von Wolkenstein (previous occupant of Castle Stanmore, who I defeated in the field of battle for the Lady’s hand) I do have new favourite Youtube vids.
See here Sir Malach of Mercilessness:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drE5cHe6c3s
makes more sense than Microsoft
The King
oops wrong link (they’re all good though)
Sorry folks
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5cWWV0KNDg&feature=related
The King
I really want the Harrington 1200.
I have no urge to sing, only to stab my eyeball with my crochet needle, that was happily making something of use, a scarf. It now has blood stains on it and I keep walking in circles to the left. (I poked out my right eye.)
Why? Someone tell me why?
Looks suspiciously like a VCS-3 doesn’t it Rev!
The King
You know, if this software ended up in the wrong hands, just THINK of the songs that could be made about Rasputin! Good thing I use a Mac, I guess…
There’s always Bootcamp…