Sun 27 Jun 2010
Shoo!TAG: Bitchfight
Posted by anaglyph under Gadgets, Hokum, Skeptical Thinking, WooWoo
[19] Comments
A recent Cow commenter, Nancy, from Sweden, tells us that ShooTag is now on sale in her country. ((And TCA saved her some money! Like any good sensible person she did some research before she forked out.)) A quick lookup verifies that yes, the ShooTaggers are making inroads into Europe with the same unfounded claims of efficacy for their product as they’ve used elsewhere. Clearly, the critical faculties of the world are in dire trouble. I even turned up this link (page has been redacted by ShooTag revisionists) which trumpets that the Finnish Olympic Team ‘is now using shoo!TAG products for protection against mosquitos !!!’ I fervently hope that this is an idle boast from the sales agent and that the Finnish Olympic Team is not so stupid as to endorse this silly item.
My friends over at the JREF have pointed out, though, that Europe might not be the virgin territory that the ShooTaggers perhaps expect. Yes folks, Europe has their own flavour of pet wootag and it’s called The Anibio Tic-Clip®.
Anibio appears to be a German company but handily, they do have a link to a pdf in English on their site which ‘explains’ how Tic-Clip works:
Ready-to-use tic-clip tags are carrying a specially charged layer of highly radiating, bioenergetic with a very high storage capacity. (Bioenergetic = dextropolarised electromagnetic energy). This creates a special oscillation-field around the tag and thus around the animal. Tics and fleas will not react to the animal anymore.
Whoa! Dextropolarised! Now there’s a word you don’t hear every day. You can look it up if you want – I did – but really, it’s one more instance of a new contextually-meaningless woo buzz word like ‘quantum’ or ‘magnetic’ and I won’t labour the point here. You can already tell that this ‘scientific’ explanation is just another load of baloney in the same vein as the ShooTag nonsense. And this one works without a clumsy magnetic strip! ShooTag! Your technology is so-o-o-o yesterday!
The pdf also urges the visitor to read this important information: ((We assume it’s important because the exhortation has lots of exclamation marks.))
This product was developed after many years of research together with the Germany based company Hess & Volk GmbH and has archived spectacular success in tic and flea prevention all over Europe. Many successful breeders are using it. Similar to holistic approaches you are unable to see or feel ((…or, in fact, determine any effect of…)) the Bioernergetic potential, but the positive results over the last couple of years are proving the strength of this toxin-free solution.
If you thought that the highlighted and underlined areas might prove to be a link to Messrs Hess & Volk’s ‘archive of spectacular success in tick and flea prevention’, I fear you will be bitterly disappointed. That would be altogether far too convenient. In fact, searching on Hess & Volk turns up lots of links pointing back to Anibio, but not much else. Now where oh where might we have seen that kind of behaviour before?
Elsewhere, an American distributor of Tic-Clip has some more enlightenment for us:
The mechanism of the Tic-Clip’s action is a bit abstract when compared with the traditional insect repellents, but this product is the result of many years of research and delivers results that dispel skepticism. Holistic products that work similarly with bioenergetic fields, like flower essences and homeopathic remedies, still lie outside the mainstream, but devoted users will tell you that the results can be truly amazing, even without their really understanding exactly how they work.
Hahahaha! The mechanism is a bit ‘abstract’? Judging by the rest of the paragraph, I think the phrase they’re looking for might be ‘The mechanism is a big steaming heap of claptrap’.
Still, maybe something’s being lost in interpretation here? Let’s go to the original German Anibio site with our friend the Babelfish and get it straight from the mund des pferdes.
Oooh. There’s a graph. That’s scientific. It’s supposed to be showing us how the Tic-Clip’s effectiveness works over time. With an efficacy of 2 years at a price of €24.90 (US$36.39) it’s MUCH better value than ShooTag’s measly 4 months for US$39.95! What does Babelfish tell us that the manufacturer is offering for that money:
Ready for use TIC tie-clip supporter contains an bioenergetic load, a special layer with high radiation potential and has a high storage capacity. In the surrounding field of the supporter, and thus in the environment of the animal (independent of its size and kind of skin), develops then a special oscillation field, which protects now dogs and cats against Zecken and fleas. The TIC tie-clip supporter is fastened with the attached rings to collar or table-ware (material plays thereby no role). On the time, on which a ring is drawn by the supporter, the TIC tie-clip up to 2 works years
OK… that’s making about as much sense as anything else we’ve read I guess. Once the Tic-Clip is properly fastened to the table-ware, it does seem to offer everything that ShooTag does at least. The Tic-Clip appears to be more robust too: the site has some caveats on effectiveness, but they don’t include the lengthy excuses that ShooTag provides for conditions under which their product might not work.
So the Tetherd Cow Ahead shoppers’ advice is: If you’re on the lookout for a completely useless product that does absolutely nothing in the way of keeping insect pests off your pets, there’s no contest – you get hugely better value for money by wasting your cash on Anibio Tic-Clip® than you do on Energetic Solutions Shoo!TAG™ ((I really wonder what the ShooTag people make of something like this. Do they scoff at the opposition: ‘That’s SO far-fetched! Look at the dumb claims they’re making! That will never work!’, or do they gaze on in envy: ‘How are they doing this without a magnetic stripe? How the hell are they achieving a 2 year efficacy? Can we steal their technology?’. My brain does little flip-flops when I try to imagine how these people think.))
19 Responses to “ Shoo!TAG: Bitchfight ”
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
[…] Via tetherdcow. com […]
Blimey, what a load of crap. Hmmm… maybe I can make special hippie-repelling handguns. Yeah, that’s right, my 9mm will keep the hippies away due to all those bioelectric energy pulses I put out….
Christ, I can’t believe people fall for this stuff….
People fall for it in a big way it seems. The pet forums are full of people endorsing these products – you can believe anything you want to if you don’t pay attention to what’s really happening.
Grats for now being the top Google hit for dextropolarised :)
It’s me now, but it was Anibio Tic-Clip up until then…
I am make two of these for the US markets;
ShooRapist
and
ShooScaryblackguy
I hope they work better than the ShooMalach I got from Nigeria.
But … but … it’s octagonal. Octagonal!
Strangely, they completely fail to list the powers of the octagon in relation to pest control.
“I even turned up this link which trumpets that the Finnish Olympic Team ‘is now using shoo!TAG products for protection against mosquitos !!!’ I fervently hope that this is an idle boast from the sales agent and that the Finnish Olympic Team is not so stupid as to endorse this silly item.”
It was an idle boast. The ad is now removed from the site.
Fan from Finland.
Thanks for the update. Another persuasive example of how the ShooTaggers operate.
I thought I’d give it a try for kicks and take or lose the $49 bucks.
So I got one for my dog. Living on an acreage my dog had an average of 9 ticks a day during tick season and fleas 2x a year.
Get this:
In first 3 weeks it went down to 1.
Now she’s been tick free for the since May 2010.
I can VERIFY it works fantastic. Plus no harmful chemicals applied to my dog.
Call it a scam but when it works I’m IN!
Sometimes if I don’t understand something I too research it and until experiencing the product firsthand it’s ALL HERESAY.
I applaud the German tic-clip brand cause it worked without fail with my dog and is still working.
Get this: You’re deluding yourself.
You can’t spell “convinced” without “con”.
I feel so late to the party here, but I’m rather enjoying the deconstruction (and demolition) of these scams.
I will give the Octoscam here some credit, though. At least it admits it’s a load – a “bioenergetic” one, at that. ;)
Oh, this party is raging well into the early hours! I doubt we’ve seen the last of Shoo!TAG yet.
I purchased the one made in Germany as I have been picking ticks off my 3 dogs all summer long. I don’t use chemicals on my dogs and I hated to spend that much money x 3 but I did. I figured I could stop payment on my Credit card or get refunded if I could not return them for not working. I must say- After bathing and combing out my 3 dogs I put attached the tags on their collars and I have only found 2 tics on the 3 dogs in the past month. I am a believer no matter how they work – they do. I will never have a dog without one on his/her neck. Great product.
Yeah, now see, the problem is that your casual observation is virtually worthless. You can’t know that the tag is responsible for you only finding ‘2 tics on the 3 dogs in the past month’ because you have nothing to measure it against – how can you possibly make a convincing argument that the same thing would have happened without the tags? That’s why we have science – to iron out observational problems. And in the case of these rubbishy gewgaws, no-one (I reiterate, no-one) has put forward ANY convincing science to show that they work, or even that there is a reason that they should work.
Also, are you related to ‘mindmatters’, who posted above, perchance? I only ask because you appear to be reading from the same cheat sheet. That, and you both apparently live in Monroe, Louisiana, which seems oddly coincidental. Maybe you should get together and have a ‘Stupid’ party.