Sat 19 Aug 2006
Irish Joke
Posted by anaglyph under Hokum, In The News, Science, Skeptical Thinking, Stupidity, Technology
[25] Comments
Speaking of laughing…
A company based in Ireland going by the name of Steorn claims to have invented a method for generating free energy. Oh dear. The old Something-For-Nothing perpetual motion delusion comes up for another breath.
You can see a comprehensively information-free piece of hype from the company here in which various Steorn personnel demonstrate the benefits of regular visits to Blarney Castle. Here’s CEO Sean McCarthy explaining why existing energy sources are problematic:
“Most of the hydrocarbons in the world, oil gas and so on, happen to be in dangerous places, they happen to be in places that are politically and economically unstable…”
Er, duh Sean. They happen to be in those places? Like there’s some kind of coincidence at work there buddy?
He goes on to divulge the secret of Steorn’s incredible new accomplishment:
“The technology is the ability to construct certain magnetic fields, that when you travel around the magnetic fields starting and stopping at the same position, you’ve suffered a net gain of energy. Quite simply the analogy would be, you walk to the top of the hill and then you walk back down to the bottom of the hill, but in doing that you’ve gained energy.”
Wow, cool analogy. Like, I’m convinced. So, if I’m understanding it correctly (bear with me, I’m not really good with all this scientific stuff) putting it another way it’s like opening doors in a hallway, and then shutting them again, and in doing so you’ve gained energy! Or, maybe, like sticking a pipe-cleaner through one ear, pulling it right through your head and out the other ear, and in doing so you’ve gained energy!
If you’re falling behind with all this technical stuff, don’t worry – the Steorn movie includes a little piece of animation that clarifies the principles at work. In it, a little green whirlpool goes round and round between some magnets:
See? Could the science behind this astonishing discovery possibly be any more persuasive?
This from Richard Walshe, Steorn’s Marketing Manager:
“There’s an ecological advantage to it, absolutely. There’s a cost saving to it, but ultimately for me, the advantage is convenience. The advantage is never having to plug your mobile phone in.”
OK. So Steorn has invented a revolutionary way of creating entirely free energy thus instantly solving all the world’s industrial, travel, pollution and communications problems as well as knocking global warming on the head (not to mention rewriting the tenets of physics in the process) and Richard is most excited about the fact that he won’t have to remember to stick his phone on charge?
I guess it’s not that unusual for the marketing arm to completely miss the point. One does wonder, though, how Steorn, with the best product EVER (forget sliced bread, forget the mousetrap, forget the wheel), has managed end up with a nitwit like Richard as their strategist.
Then again, maybe the members of Steorn are crazy like foxes. The company has taken out an ad in The Economist challenging scientists to prove them wrong. You’ve gotta give them points for chutzpah. With some major scientific hoo-hah and a few serious-sounding names in the fray they could spin this hogwash out for, hey, maybe a couple of years and bring all kinds of investment money on board.
And they’re no strangers to that game.
My advice? Before you throw your hard-earned cash into Steorn’s Magical Magnetic Moolah Magnifier, take a trip to The Museum of Unworkable Devices and ponder the old saw ‘There’s no such thing as a free lunch’.
It holds just as true for the Laws of Physics and investment strategies as it does for interpersonal relationships.
25 Responses to “ Irish Joke ”
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
[…] I’m calling bullshit on this one. So is this reasonable analysis. Would any of my more technical readership care to confirm? […]
-
[…] It occurs to me that there is a scientific equation that can be solved here. Madonna is rich and, with very little acumen about just how it might be done, wants to solve all the world’s problems. On the other side of the plus sign, the Steorn crackpots are looking for gullible air-heads with plenty of spare cash. If only someone would put them together – then they might amuse one another for years and leave the rest of us alone. […]
-
[…] 5. Irish Joke – Not-so-friendly reaction to Steorn’s free energy claims, including a particularly cutting reaction to Steorn’s marketing manager saying in the promotional video that the most exciting thing about the technology would be not having to charge your cell phone or stop for gas. (www.tetherdcow.com) […]
-
[…] OK. Now I’ve found something that tops even the Steorn bozos’ concepts for sheer technical daftness. Or downright thievery – you decide. […]
-
[…] a year ago here on The Cow we had cause to examine the Irish company Steorn and their announcement of the discovery of a remarkable way of creating […]
-
[…] energy out of nothing? We examined their preposterous claims on The Cow almost two years ago, here, and then again, after they comprehensively failed to reveal their stunning breakthrough to the […]
-
[…] had to say: “CowLink™ worked for me! I bought one for everyone in my company!” ~ Sean McCarthy, […]
-
[…] farms and hydro schemes! Yes, my friends, tomorrow (Saturday January 30, 2010) our old friends at Steorn are going to demonstrate once and for all, conclusive and unequivocal PROOF that their overunity1 […]
Steorn – I thought I might never see anything sillier than Father Ted, but there’tis.
I hope it is a hoax but it is more likely they’ll be taking a quid off people.
It looks quite similar to a shite machine touted here in Oz (well in Queensland at least. The rest of us often worry about them.) They need JUST A LITTLE BIT MORE MONEY to make a proper working prototype…..
Keep up the good work.
Martin Hadley (President, Australian Skeptics)
Hello Martin, thanks for dropping by.
Sadly, Steorn seems to be completely serious (well, as serious as loons can be) and there can only be two possibilities: they either believe what they say, and are in for a very unhappy realisation at some point, or they are fully aware of their scam and will milk it for every penny they can before skulking off into the shadows to re-emerge with their next hair-brained idea (which, as I’m sure you know, is often the MO of such people).
I can only appeal to my readers: if you are thinking of forking out your hard-earned cash on a Perpetual Motion Free Energy Gadget, DON’T. Send it to The Cow instead, where we will spend it on whisky and piss it away for you.
I’m confused. The pictured magnet with the little lightning bolts will both – I believe the scientific terms are “pull” and “push” – the (radioactive? cool!) green thing, yes? To achieve a net gain, one of these must exceed the other, yes? But no matter how much I stare at the picture, the two bolts stay the same size. Hence my confusion.
Unless… hmm. If I send money, will the bolts then differentiate?
I’m sorry I don’t think I can bring myself to believe this until Dubya announces that he believes in it, too. (Then it’s okay.)
RaJ: Yes, please send money. Then I will send you another equally vague illustration, that will cost me less than you pay me for it. Then we do it again. Pretty quickly I get to see more coming out of this exchange than I put into it. See how it works? Oh what’s that? You want to get something out of it too?
jmf: Dubya is pretty stupid, but he is never going to believe in this, even if by some miracle the science is proven (one could speculate especially if the science is proven…)
“What FREE ENERGY? FREE? Are you mad?”
I remember from my high school physics that when I walk up a hill I expend energy but gain Kinetic energy but when I walk down the hill I lose the Kinetic Energy that I gained (thus energy is conserved) If I went to a hill with a cliff, (where I would naturally encounter a sign with Simple Graphics Man) and walked off the cliff my kinetic energy would be converted instantly into a gravitational attraction until I encountered a resting energy (at the foot of the cliff) again energy is conserved. So really the example is terribly non scientific and I doubt whether I will be investing my hard earned dollars in their venture.
hewhohears: Well, that’s just the kind of blinkered Philistine attitude I’ve come to expect from you non-creative garbage…
See, where you go completely wrong is that there are no magnets involved in your example. Magnets, my friend, magnets. If you spent a little less time walking up and down hills and more time sticking things to your fridge you’d undertand where we’re at here.
Dear Reverend,
It was not I who mentioned Hills sans Lodestone, I merely used their example
Hmm. The old lodestone, eh? Now that’s a natural form of magnetism, isn’t it? I like the way you’re thinking young lad. A kind of organic magnetism, if you like. So we could promote a much better class of energy than Steorn; they might have Free Energy, but we could have Wholistic Free Range Biodynamic Organic Energy.
There ought to be some increasing returns from that…
I’d be tempted to invest if Sean hadn’t said I would “suffer a net gain of energy”. I don’t like suffering. Unless it’s pre-dated by whisky.
How long have sientists known that concentrations o hydrocarbons cause politickal n economic instability?
Thanks for sharing. What a plesurae to read!
No problems Amber! What a swell lass you are, giving us yet another chance to provide a link to the JREF!
GsHOtm xsvtbzkdiajr
[This spam kept intact for reference. Garbage links redirected.]
Cissy Strutt: Yes, it is a curious choice of words. One is reminded of the old wisdom not to suffer fools gladly.
Joey: Nearly as long as they’ve known that concentrations of magnets and money cause mental instability.
ABC’s “Lost” Season 3 premieres on Wednesday, October 4.
Yeah, see it doesn’t surprise me in the least that Steorn is tied up with spammers too.