Here in New South Wales, Australia we are in the throes of a State election along with all the accompanying heehaw of such an event.
So last night I had a phone call from a marketing company that wanted to get my ‘opinion’ on the field. This was the conversation as it happened:
Polite Young Woman: Do you mind if I ask you some questions about the current political situation in the state?
Reverend: Not at all. As long as you ask sensible questions.
PYW: Oh… er… OK. Um, which is your preferred candidate out of Mr Transparent and Mr Translucent.
Reverend: I don’t have a preference between those two.
PYW: Oh. So shall I mark ‘Not Sure’?
Reverend: Those are my options? Mr Transparent, Mr Translucent or ‘Not Sure’.
PYW: Er. Yes…
Reverend: But I am sure. I’m sure that I don’t prefer either of those. I’m voting for The Principles Party[tippy title=”¹”]We have more of an option than just the two ‘main’ candidates, although neither of them live, apparently, in a universe which allows this possibility.[/tippy]
PYW: Well, you can only have one of those two or ‘Not Sure’. It’s which of those you prefer. You don’t have to vote for them.
Reverend: Are you asking “If I only had one life preserver and the ship was sinking, which one would I throw it to?”
PYW: I guess so. Sort of.
Reverend: [Thinks: Who made up this survey? Do they want results or do they just want to hear answers upon which they’ve already formatted policy?] In that case, I’m not sure.
PYW: [Thinks: I knew I was getting desperate when I took on this job] O-k-a-y (makes computer key clicking noise). Now, how would you describe your satisfaction with the policies of the Transparent Party currently in power: ‘Satisfied’ or ‘Not Satisfied’?
Reverend: That’s it? ‘Satisfied’ or ‘Not Satisfied’?
PYW: [Sighs] Or ‘Not Sure’.
Reverend: Why don’t you just fill in all my answers as ‘Not Sure’. It will be quicker.
I propose a different kind of tack with such surveys. It would go like this:
•If Candidate A and Candidate B were in a burning building, and you could rescue only one person would you:
A: Rescue Candidate A?
B: Rescue Candidate B?
C: Watch the building burn while playing the violin?
•Given the ineffectual policies of both the main political parties, do you:
A: Prefer the ineffectual policies currently in place?
B: Prefer the ineffectual policies offered by the opposition?
C: Think that the money spent on this survey should be used to buy everyone violins?
I’m prepared to wager that the outcome would be the same, but with my version at least we’d all have music and a bonfire.
___________________________________________________________________________
¹We have more of an option than just the two ‘main’ candidates, although neither of them live, apparently, in a universe which allows this possibility
___________________________________________________________________________